Difference between revisions of "PDR.PODM Distributed Memory"

From crtc.cs.odu.edu
Jump to: navigation, search
(→‎Interesting Findings)
(→‎Interesting Findings)
Line 32: Line 32:
 
= Interesting Findings =
 
= Interesting Findings =
 
[[File:PDR PODM Parallelism.png| 700px]]
 
[[File:PDR PODM Parallelism.png| 700px]]
 +
[[File:PDR PODM Histogram 15.png| 700px]]
  
 
* How many times migrated a leaf (main and neighbor) ?
 
* How many times migrated a leaf (main and neighbor) ?

Revision as of 22:26, 10 April 2020

Issues

  • No reuse of leaves refined by worker nodes. The picture below shows the issue. Two neighbour leaves (0,1) each refined as the main leaf (0 top, 1 bottom) but not refined as a neighor.

PDR PODM Leaves not refined.png

  • Current algorithm uses neighbour traversal to distribute cells to octree leaving some cells out in some cases. Such a case can happen when a cell is part of an octree leaf based on its circumcenter but

it does not have any neighbour in the same leaf.

PDR PODM Cells not distributed.png

  • During unpacking the incident cell for each vertex is not set correctly. Specifically, in the case that the initial incident cell is not part of the working unit (Leaf + LVL.1 Neighbours) and thus is not local,

it is set to the infinite cell. This causes PODM to crash randomly for some cases.

  • Another issue comes from the way global IDs are updated for each cell's neighbors' IDs. The code that updates the cell's connectivity using global IDs takes the neighbor's pointer, retrieves its global ID and

updates the neighborID field. However, when the neighbour is part of another work unit's leaf and is not local this pointer is NULL. In this case the neighborID field is wrongly reset to the infinite cell ID, which as result, deletes the connectivity information forever.

  • The function that unpacks the required leaves before refinement does not discard duplicate vertices. Duplicate vertices will always be present since each leaf is packed and sent individually, and as a result,

neighbouring leaves will include the shared vertices. Because duplicate vertices are not handled, multiple vertex objects are created that are in fact the same point geometrically. Thus, two cells that share a common vertex could have pointers to two different vertex objects and, as a result, each cell views a different state about the same vertex.

Fixes

PDR Fix.png

Work Unit After Refinement.png


Interesting Findings

PDR PODM Parallelism.png PDR PODM Histogram 15.png

  • How many times migrated a leaf (main and neighbor) ?
  • How many times a leaf is scheduled ? (as main leaf)
  • Packed size for each transmission (MB)/time?
  • Meshing time each time it was main
  • Initial meshing time
  • Per process :
    • Meshing
    • Preprocessing (pack/unpack)
    • waiting time
  • Waiting time per process ?
  • Elements before and after each time it was used (main/neighbor) ?
leaf_id init elements num_migrations num_scheduled num_refined max_size_migration (KB) min_size_migration (KB) avg_size_migration (KB) max_time_migration (sec) min_time_migration (sec) avg_time_migration (sec)
0 5140 1 0 1
1 4921 1 0 1
2 4880 1 0 1
3 4714 1 0 1
4 5044 1 0 1
5 4668 1 0 1
6 4741 1 0 1
7 4470 1 1 0
8 4854 1 0 1
9 4733 1 0 1
10 4628 1 0 1
11 4719 1 0 1
12 4747 1 0 1
13 4692 1 0 1
14 4484 1 0 1
15 4439 1 0 1
16 4847 2 0 2 415 415 415.0 0.000405 0.000405 0.000405
17 4597 6 0 6 394 394 394.0 0.015056 0.000377 0.003564199999999999
18 4875 4 0 4 417 417 417.0 0.030162 0.000719 0.016067
19 4704 9 0 9 405 404 404.0 0.019694 0.000544 0.007640875
20 4611 2 0 2 395 395 395.0 0.000401 0.000401 0.000401
21 4515 10 0 10 387 387 387.0 0.023126 0.000373 0.0037203333333333324
22 4715 7 0 7 404 404 404.0 0.016818 0.000444 0.006300166666666667
23 4557 21 1 20 403 394 400.0 0.04192 0.000398 0.01055885
24 4570 10 0 10 392 392 392.0 0.030502 0.000373 0.00599111111111111
25 4666 13 0 13 400 400 400.0 0.047174 0.00068 0.01136525
26 4746 15 0 15 531 407 510.0 0.049097 0.00055 0.00914507142857143
27 4868 17 0 17 621 417 593.0 0.052032 0.000761 0.014502000000000001
28 4481 19 0 19 384 384 384.0 0.019985 0.000293 0.0026930555555555557
29 4509 26 0 26 387 387 387.0 0.034138 0.000437 0.006108079999999999
30 4590 34 4 30 10613 395 8870.0 1.144701 0.000322 0.13719339393939395
31 4752 39 4 35 20063 415 15899.0 2.210566 0.000639 0.17472076315789475
32 4904 1 0 1
33 4767 1 0 1
34 4667 1 0 1
35 4510 1 0 1
36 4929 1 0 1
37 4771 1 0 1
38 4754 1 0 1
39 4459 1 0 1
40 4686 1 0 1
41 4609 1 0 1
42 4489 1 0 1
43 4465 1 0 1
44 4641 1 0 1
45 4707 1 0 1
46 4539 1 0 1
47 4540 1 0 1
48 4813 3 0 3 412 412 412.0 0.000928 0.000405 0.0006665
49 4425 17 0 17 380 380 380.0 0.012858 0.000314 0.0024941250000000002
50 4620 11 0 11 396 396 396.0 0.022816 0.000463 0.006890599999999999
51 4525 32 0 32 388 388 388.0 0.061139 0.000387 0.00679132258064516
52 4762 4 0 4 408 408 408.0 0.046096 0.018953 0.031662
53 4583 19 0 19 393 393 393.0 0.018943 0.000514 0.006347722222222222
54 4628 14 0 14 397 397 397.0 0.041793 0.000596 0.012489384615384614
55 4521 38 1 37 394 389 393.0 0.040649 0.000447 0.009107486486486486
56 4533 33 0 33 388 388 388.0 0.029611 0.000359 0.004132593750000001
57 4476 46 0 46 384 384 384.0 0.038396 0.000364 0.006301111111111111
58 4603 54 4 50 9376 395 8107.0 0.805219 0.000388 0.08217690566037736
59 4798 63 5 58 22391 411 21441.0 2.142464 0.000345 0.19465403225806455
60 4490 36 0 36 385 385 385.0 0.023103 0.000337 0.005721457142857143
61 4512 45 0 45 387 387 387.0 0.038251 0.000424 0.00701115909090909
62 4582 60 6 54 9883 393 8875.0 1.112903 0.000483 0.10731481355932204
63 4699 67 7 60 21908 403 21305.0 1.537622 0.000399 0.1713687424242424
64 4818 1 0 1
65 4816 2 0 2 412 412 412.0 0.00045 0.00045 0.00045
66 4626 1 0 1
67 4727 2 0 2 405 405 405.0 0.000464 0.000464 0.000464
68 4623 1 0 1
69 4837 2 0 2 414 414 414.0 0.000473 0.000473 0.000473
70 4454 1 1 0
71 4429 2 0 2 381 381 381.0 0.000438 0.000438 0.000438
72 4896 1 0 1
73 5117 1 0 1
74 4669 1 0 1
75 4841 1 0 1
76 4804 1 0 1
77 4988 1 0 1
78 4587 1 1 0
79 4616 1 0 1
80 4746 15 0 15 407 407 407.0 0.018839 0.000579 0.010480928571428572
81 4600 17 0 17 394 394 394.0 0.033308 0.000398 0.0047910625
82 4909 22 0 22 627 429 571.0 0.051229 0.000809 0.014659999999999996
83 4768 25 0 25 607 408 570.0 0.054998 0.000675 0.013141125000000002
84 4596 31 0 31 394 394 394.0 0.018374 0.000358 0.005900033333333332
85 4484 33 0 33 385 385 385.0 0.040269 0.000366 0.00621278125
86 4879 45 4 41 21582 818 14618.0 0.856606 0.000981 0.086496
87 4722 54 6 48 19733 413 15960.0 1.694223 0.000403 0.22801369811320754
88 4637 12 0 12 397 397 397.0 0.0184 0.000352 0.006041727272727273
89 4901 6 0 6 419 419 419.0 0.024881 0.000641 0.0060704
90 4698 19 0 19 527 515 522.0 0.032079 0.000546 0.012114944444444442
91 4873 9 0 9 418 418 418.0 0.011423 0.000847 0.004115875
92 4534 24 0 24 388 388 388.0 0.021887 0.00037 0.005878608695652173
93 4708 11 0 11 403 403 403.0 0.015462 0.000409 0.0031311999999999998
94 4609 42 5 37 10745 520 10079.0 0.66151 0.001178 0.13872612195121953
95 4558 22 0 22 408 391 405.0 0.031273 0.000437 0.007883619047619047
96 4594 1 0 1
97 4676 3 0 3 401 401 401.0 0.000473 0.000463 0.000468
98 4465 1 0 1
99 4467 3 0 3 384 384 384.0 0.00045 0.000442 0.000446
100 4726 1 0 1
101 4658 2 0 2 399 399 399.0 0.000494 0.000494 0.000494
102 4508 1 0 1
103 4525 2 0 2 388 388 388.0 0.00049 0.00049 0.00049
104 4718 2 0 2 405 405 405.0 0.000476 0.000476 0.000476
105 4967 2 0 2 425 425 425.0 0.00051 0.00051 0.00051
106 4481 2 0 2 385 385 385.0 0.000452 0.000452 0.000452
107 4571 2 0 2 392 392 392.0 0.000471 0.000471 0.000471
108 4786 1 0 1
109 4823 1 0 1
110 4574 1 1 0
111 4680 1 0 1
112 4574 51 0 51 392 392 392.0 0.047324 0.000392 0.005151880000000001
113 4489 52 0 52 385 385 385.0 0.060409 0.000312 0.005352901960784314
114 4736 72 4 68 23594 414 17669.0 1.006988 0.000343 0.08559649295774648
115 4735 83 7 76 22078 406 18987.0 2.747555 0.000391 0.22780202439024386
116 4481 47 0 47 385 385 385.0 0.03056 0.000375 0.005288021739130433
117 4531 46 0 46 389 389 389.0 0.043212 0.000331 0.006133044444444443
118 4789 69 7 62 20996 418 17145.0 1.757034 0.000356 0.1959893823529412
119 4608 81 6 75 21187 396 18847.0 2.456932 0.000378 0.22400851249999998
120 4518 36 0 36 387 387 387.0 0.028003 0.000351 0.004179828571428572
121 4695 17 0 17 402 402 402.0 0.036991 0.000394 0.005922875
122 4632 63 5 58 8865 463 8604.0 0.732422 0.000591 0.10695459677419356
123 4671 33 0 33 401 400 401.0 0.026674 0.000354 0.007890125000000001
124 4484 33 0 33 385 385 385.0 0.036508 0.000326 0.006485437499999999
125 4649 16 0 16 399 399 399.0 0.025154 0.00034 0.006072800000000001
126 4461 60 5 55 6350 5843 6265.0 0.527465 0.008833 0.08390650847457627
127 4697 34 0 34 403 403 403.0 0.033889 0.00043 0.006612545454545454
128 5001 5 0 5 429 429 429.0 0.017186 0.000428 0.00848025
129 4783 14 0 14 499 491 494.0 0.071658 0.000541 0.015102230769230767
130 4770 5 0 5 408 408 408.0 0.036432 0.000566 0.012671
131 4780 12 0 12 467 412 438.0 0.03341 0.000402 0.012121272727272725
132 4577 10 0 10 392 392 392.0 0.020947 0.000367 0.006680222222222223
133 4618 31 3 28 5218 4818 4942.0 0.351238 0.006392 0.0750992
134 4663 10 0 10 399 399 399.0 0.037043 0.000432 0.009523222222222221
135 4555 28 1 27 3236 470 1796.0 0.107946 0.000541 0.023689148148148147
136 4842 24 0 24 833 421 538.0 0.08271 0.000418 0.013151782608695652
137 4958 27 0 27 840 433 655.0 0.063228 0.000467 0.014496038461538463
138 4799 22 0 22 813 412 730.0 0.055436 0.000558 0.007774952380952382
139 4911 26 0 26 842 421 739.0 0.123103 0.000465 0.025620559999999997
140 4801 55 1 54 35078 764 10374.0 2.521878 0.000641 0.10560070370370372
141 4818 62 2 60 35230 814 21732.0 1.25825 0.00093 0.14713504918032783
142 4742 53 4 49 33400 415 27391.0 1.310808 0.000573 0.2354048461538462
143 4829 61 4 57 35186 421 26418.0 3.787715 0.000825 0.30994716666666655
144 4887 2 0 2 418 418 418.0 0.014348 0.014348 0.014348
145 4587 8 0 8 393 393 393.0 0.040848 0.000721 0.010354142857142857
146 5103 1 0 1
147 4833 3 0 3 414 414 414.0 0.016732 0.000898 0.008815
148 4692 4 0 4 402 402 402.0 0.033889 0.000556 0.016683
149 4557 16 1 15 391 391 391.0 0.018683 0.000472 0.004319266666666668
150 4964 1 0 1
151 4674 6 0 6 400 400 400.0 0.028551 0.000983 0.013714399999999998
152 4799 16 0 16 493 411 482.0 0.037937 0.000534 0.0101036
153 4674 21 0 21 678 661 674.0 0.09922 0.000717 0.018367699999999994
154 4845 7 0 7 415 415 415.0 0.00591 0.00042 0.002009
155 4861 11 0 11 417 417 417.0 0.032705 0.000533 0.0148554
156 4616 37 2 35 10955 396 9495.0 0.84543 0.000558 0.14547416666666665
157 4896 47 4 43 29802 814 28902.0 1.4604 0.005043 0.23156036956521733
158 4867 16 0 16 418 417 418.0 0.036092 0.000502 0.011479066666666666
159 4743 24 0 24 514 415 507.0 0.052268 0.000587 0.017611521739130432
160 4728 20 0 20 406 406 406.0 0.020009 0.000408 0.008198631578947367
161 4539 53 3 50 1305 410 954.0 0.092867 0.000431 0.013970576923076926
162 4650 22 0 22 398 398 398.0 0.027525 0.000387 0.00920314285714286
163 4462 51 2 49 1281 384 1026.0 0.173192 0.000357 0.012442220000000002
164 4741 25 0 25 407 407 407.0 0.027902 0.000388 0.006532625
165 4557 61 3 58 3903 486 1465.0 0.084045 0.000469 0.012070450000000003
166 4749 28 0 28 408 408 408.0 0.036397 0.000423 0.005662185185185185
167 4547 62 6 56 5675 393 4951.0 0.556404 0.000379 0.06199437704918033
168 4811 90 5 85 33750 417 18049.0 2.345832 0.000446 0.1369888876404494
169 4866 97 2 95 35510 426 18884.0 2.747791 0.000411 0.22452585416666662
170 4733 89 3 86 34065 406 28104.0 1.726143 0.00034 0.19082899999999994
171 5014 95 7 88 35596 430 23707.0 3.052361 0.000409 0.22742587234042558
172 4820 96 1 95 34465 421 7042.0 0.218778 0.000472 0.03614748421052631
173 4922 101 2 99 35520 430 19368.0 3.092187 0.000365 0.15891331
174 4901 96 5 91 35540 420 26870.0 4.254684 0.000395 0.25204304210526324
175 5132 101 4 97 35517 439 27090.0 2.22364 0.000619 0.18806341
176 4672 13 0 13 400 400 400.0 0.029952 0.000399 0.009411
177 4585 35 0 35 394 393 394.0 0.032544 0.00043 0.0068634117647058835
178 4895 4 0 4 419 419 419.0 0.020005 0.000999 0.009127999999999999
179 4585 14 0 14 393 393 393.0 0.036209 0.000378 0.00787546153846154
180 4775 17 0 17 410 410 410.0 0.028318 0.000435 0.00724625
181 4460 42 3 39 555 387 538.0 0.052798 0.000598 0.012619195121951218
182 4883 6 0 6 418 418 418.0 0.032337 0.00095 0.010706400000000001
183 4655 19 0 19 398 398 398.0 0.029974 0.000575 0.009053555555555558
184 4798 67 3 64 20596 411 18456.0 1.975423 0.000372 0.24117915151515149
185 4741 77 6 71 35275 803 34594.0 2.824109 0.001208 0.24719185526315796
186 4787 31 0 31 517 410 493.0 0.039667 0.000379 0.0081323
187 4709 43 0 43 817 412 803.0 0.075649 0.000401 0.019051404761904762
188 4792 71 5 66 25521 804 23645.0 1.902453 0.001311 0.2771063428571429
189 4848 78 7 71 35180 33582 34843.0 1.660215 0.052097 0.22248788311688308
190 4672 35 0 35 539 410 519.0 0.048332 0.000468 0.014152470588235292
191 4668 44 0 44 813 787 805.0 0.079299 0.00091 0.01713302325581395
192 4925 32 0 32 842 815 827.0 0.066662 0.001037 0.017131677419354837
193 4824 35 0 35 838 422 565.0 0.070966 0.000469 0.012869823529411765
194 4929 33 0 33 838 431 545.0 0.0761 0.000461 0.010275656250000003
195 5073 37 0 37 857 435 680.0 0.080225 0.000457 0.013417944444444446
196 5103 68 2 66 35249 33674 34415.0 2.730947 0.049441 0.22863904477611938
197 4888 77 4 73 35319 816 14284.0 1.240214 0.001182 0.10229803947368421
198 4840 71 2 69 35261 808 11567.0 1.443657 0.000858 0.09159465714285712
199 4888 80 4 76 35230 428 18831.0 2.501586 0.00039 0.20689413924050631
200 4728 27 0 27 809 414 671.0 0.034728 0.000428 0.008012884615384614
201 5041 13 0 13 441 432 437.0 0.034372 0.000528 0.007971250000000001
202 4847 28 0 28 808 420 748.0 0.065262 0.000702 0.014953111111111108
203 4908 14 0 14 427 421 425.0 0.021254 0.000447 0.004600615384615384
204 4647 60 4 56 34849 404 19815.0 1.498058 0.000727 0.1357884576271186
205 4766 33 0 33 802 408 598.0 0.057507 0.000471 0.008826031249999998
206 4697 62 4 58 32343 640 22419.0 1.908858 0.000594 0.2163177540983606
207 4657 34 0 34 660 399 549.0 0.045163 0.00034 0.008172454545454544
208 4784 25 0 25 665 414 559.0 0.098567 0.000493 0.010815208333333333
209 4789 27 0 27 652 415 587.0 0.04927 0.000755 0.008286576923076924
210 4903 15 0 15 420 420 420.0 0.033982 0.000423 0.008029357142857144
211 4868 17 0 17 418 418 418.0 0.02337 0.000375 0.0108668125
212 4946 56 5 51 29192 432 13847.0 1.780761 0.00083 0.21104609090909096
213 4782 57 6 51 25840 613 15069.0 1.086749 0.000654 0.1849354285714286
214 4662 33 0 33 496 400 435.0 0.068018 0.000394 0.013121562499999998
215 4705 34 0 34 424 404 415.0 0.034822 0.000379 0.009416333333333332
216 4791 20 0 20 470 463 468.0 0.032153 0.000722 0.008768894736842102
217 4913 10 0 10 421 421 421.0 0.032853 0.000919 0.008131888888888888
218 4898 12 0 12 420 420 420.0 0.017379 0.000882 0.00776381818181818
219 5131 6 0 6 439 439 439.0 0.039579 0.000904 0.016645600000000003
220 4633 43 6 37 6194 5740 6012.0 0.663521 0.00775 0.09799988095238095
221 4604 22 0 22 395 395 395.0 0.031822 0.000335 0.007726523809523809
222 4693 25 0 25 402 402 402.0 0.042673 0.000347 0.011762958333333335
223 4852 11 0 11 416 416 416.0 0.032192 0.000376 0.0140429
224 5129 105 2 103 35629 834 10904.0 1.313984 0.000826 0.07052285576923077
225 4807 118 3 115 35596 421 13050.0 1.741935 0.000428 0.08700684615384614
226 5067 109 3 106 35571 442 10643.0 1.891894 0.000451 0.07780433333333334
227 5074 122 3 119 35594 434 13368.0 1.853441 0.00046 0.12165690909090908
228 5124 102 1 101 35642 830 4125.0 1.295953 0.000978 0.035116
229 4867 118 4 114 35667 425 10893.0 2.992325 0.000421 0.15099828205128202
230 5084 106 2 104 35719 443 5771.0 1.426547 0.000462 0.036069704761904756
231 5047 123 4 119 35571 433 17022.0 1.856241 0.000405 0.17661686885245903
232 4688 91 8 83 30024 407 19189.0 1.538931 0.00042 0.16070555555555555
233 4685 50 0 50 466 402 438.0 0.033421 0.000364 0.004877795918367347
234 4849 94 7 87 27433 420 21737.0 2.013652 0.000462 0.21656583870967744
235 4749 51 0 51 431 407 424.0 0.038251 0.000408 0.007048679999999999
236 4734 88 6 82 26492 636 19175.0 2.213252 0.000884 0.20057063218390805
237 4618 51 0 51 399 396 397.0 0.039464 0.000356 0.006376559999999999
238 4849 90 6 84 26933 420 25067.0 2.684458 0.000411 0.2438207528089887
239 4611 51 0 51 398 396 398.0 0.034461 0.000375 0.009286019999999999
240 4792 87 4 83 35199 418 27784.0 2.947441 0.000439 0.24737167441860455
241 4888 88 8 80 34145 422 29209.0 3.038667 0.000449 0.28930131034482776
242 4888 54 0 54 834 419 696.0 0.060277 0.000397 0.013741905660377356
243 4770 53 0 53 732 409 662.0 0.057123 0.000396 0.008603365384615385
244 4858 83 7 76 35283 808 31108.0 2.79696 0.001199 0.29113229268292684
245 4740 86 7 79 34881 414 31750.0 2.356987 0.00043 0.28524752941176473
246 4802 50 0 50 833 420 753.0 0.078215 0.000421 0.016389816326530613
247 4793 49 0 49 794 410 743.0 0.073413 0.000413 0.012781625000000003
248 4579 65 5 60 8885 470 8654.0 0.668934 0.000592 0.1190871875
249 4770 33 0 33 409 409 409.0 0.03466 0.000364 0.00937528125
250 4775 37 0 37 410 410 410.0 0.040477 0.000378 0.007337555555555554
251 4974 16 0 16 426 426 426.0 0.042725 0.000416 0.010310999999999999
252 4625 62 5 57 11588 505 11335.0 0.897079 0.000747 0.14752404918032785
253 4691 32 0 32 402 402 402.0 0.037126 0.000361 0.010469322580645162
254 4617 34 0 34 400 396 399.0 0.026872 0.000357 0.008994151515151514
255 4872 15 0 15 417 417 417.0 0.048537 0.000463 0.014429857142857145
256 5234 1 0 1
257 4651 1 0 1
258 4671 1 0 1
259 4538 1 1 0
260 4869 2 0 2 418 418 418.0 0.000393 0.000393 0.000393
261 4671 2 0 2 400 400 400.0 0.000377 0.000377 0.000377
262 4724 2 0 2 405 405 405.0 0.000385 0.000385 0.000385
263 4521 2 0 2 388 388 388.0 0.000367 0.000367 0.000367
264 4664 1 0 1
265 4673 1 0 1
266 4515 1 0 1
267 4513 1 0 1
268 4666 2 0 2 400 400 400.0 0.000386 0.000386 0.000386
269 4558 2 0 2 391 391 391.0 0.000835 0.000835 0.000835
270 4510 2 0 2 386 386 386.0 0.000364 0.000364 0.000364
271 4569 2 0 2 392 392 392.0 0.000979 0.000979 0.000979
272 4784 9 0 9 410 410 410.0 0.031732 0.000407 0.0154075
273 4564 26 0 26 391 391 391.0 0.029549 0.000406 0.0072178
274 4513 18 0 18 387 387 387.0 0.022865 0.0005 0.007096
275 4623 43 2 41 1022 475 887.0 0.095425 0.000505 0.0129385
276 4625 13 0 13 396 396 396.0 0.01638 0.000374 0.0026061666666666664
277 4448 30 0 30 381 381 381.0 0.022676 0.000334 0.007312275862068967
278 4669 22 0 22 400 400 400.0 0.031952 0.000445 0.007112190476190477
279 4555 51 5 46 2084 392 1823.0 0.18679 0.000434 0.02254728
280 4579 44 0 44 393 393 393.0 0.030298 0.000337 0.007696604651162791
281 4548 49 0 49 390 390 390.0 0.038349 0.000415 0.007028229166666667
282 4609 68 5 63 15042 401 10994.0 1.12152 0.000535 0.11490973134328362
283 4522 71 5 66 22051 395 14898.0 1.732319 0.00041 0.18782437142857147
284 4517 47 0 47 387 387 387.0 0.026073 0.000347 0.006048499999999999
285 4468 49 0 49 383 383 383.0 0.051758 0.000349 0.00749775
286 4629 78 6 72 17070 396 13240.0 1.05898 0.000353 0.1782791558441558
287 4560 83 6 77 24214 391 19350.0 1.801677 0.000539 0.15831074390243902
288 4873 1 0 1
289 4669 1 0 1
290 4675 1 0 1
291 4513 1 1 0
292 4929 1 0 1
293 5066 1 0 1
294 4898 1 0 1
295 4664 1 0 1
296 4691 1 0 1
297 4692 1 0 1
298 4497 1 0 1
299 4513 1 0 1
300 5283 1 0 1
301 4870 1 0 1
302 4666 1 0 1
303 4626 1 0 1
304 4698 10 0 10 403 403 403.0 0.022218 0.000496 0.007235666666666666
305 4364 22 0 22 374 374 374.0 0.025065 0.000348 0.008061333333333334
306 4743 15 0 15 407 407 407.0 0.042199 0.000556 0.010222642857142857
307 4534 36 4 32 3796 3500 3751.0 0.339467 0.004786 0.04757462857142857
308 4876 5 0 5 418 418 418.0 0.001252 0.000553 0.00085425
309 4606 11 0 11 394 394 394.0 0.027692 0.000346 0.004638000000000001
310 4846 8 0 8 415 415 415.0 0.032326 0.00048 0.006603
311 4659 19 0 19 446 441 445.0 0.031849 0.000426 0.006205500000000001
312 4480 34 0 34 385 385 385.0 0.039385 0.000337 0.008765848484848484
313 4500 37 0 37 386 386 386.0 0.031724 0.000372 0.007139055555555557
314 4620 57 6 51 17655 516 16870.0 1.384116 0.000595 0.2914791428571429
315 4704 62 6 56 24510 23497 24332.0 3.002376 0.033815 0.30594893442622956
316 4647 17 0 17 398 398 398.0 0.02186 0.000347 0.0048635625
317 4652 20 0 20 399 399 399.0 0.024712 0.000374 0.005520368421052632
318 4784 30 0 30 621 412 603.0 0.049087 0.000383 0.009207137931034483
319 4775 36 0 36 702 689 699.0 0.073271 0.000809 0.02001354285714286
320 4667 1 0 1
321 4609 2 0 2 395 395 395.0 0.000479 0.000479 0.000479
322 4479 1 1 0
323 4526 2 0 2 388 388 388.0 0.00048 0.00048 0.00048
324 4683 2 0 2 402 402 402.0 0.000982 0.000982 0.000982
325 4626 3 0 3 397 397 397.0 0.000728 0.000455 0.0005915
326 4427 2 0 2 380 380 380.0 0.005516 0.005516 0.005516
327 4560 3 0 3 391 391 391.0 0.000854 0.000505 0.0006795
328 4695 1 0 1
329 4812 1 0 1
330 4414 1 0 1
331 4847 1 0 1
332 4680 1 0 1
333 5107 1 0 1
334 4459 1 0 1
335 4684 1 0 1
336 4476 47 0 47 384 384 384.0 0.050207 0.000405 0.006834717391304347
337 4530 45 0 45 389 389 389.0 0.039705 0.000359 0.006810113636363635
338 4679 73 1 72 20668 790 13127.0 0.885686 0.000988 0.1188362361111111
339 4551 80 4 76 22115 398 15998.0 1.533126 0.000373 0.18685337974683539
340 4438 46 0 46 381 381 381.0 0.034865 0.000346 0.005006955555555557
341 4535 45 0 45 389 389 389.0 0.045882 0.000314 0.005172159090909092
342 4583 83 5 78 25585 401 16405.0 2.383814 0.000477 0.17421218292682927
343 4616 88 5 83 23634 396 20156.0 1.244632 0.000397 0.13510183908045975
344 4405 31 0 31 378 378 378.0 0.019572 0.00033 0.005825899999999999
345 4587 16 0 16 394 394 394.0 0.037612 0.000338 0.006420733333333334
346 4625 59 5 54 11188 492 10465.0 0.971001 0.00074 0.15938786206896552
347 4681 32 0 32 404 402 403.0 0.044012 0.000363 0.008428870967741937
348 4516 30 0 30 387 387 387.0 0.018138 0.000428 0.005765896551724139
349 4644 16 0 16 398 398 398.0 0.028985 0.000383 0.0034938666666666667
350 4576 61 5 56 14406 564 14023.0 0.8327 0.000917 0.1307434
351 4634 32 0 32 445 400 442.0 0.030715 0.000381 0.010195903225806451
352 4695 1 0 1
353 4604 2 0 2 394 394 394.0 0.000634 0.000634 0.000634
354 4535 1 1 0
355 4542 2 0 2 390 390 390.0 0.000964 0.000964 0.000964
356 4827 1 0 1
357 4861 2 0 2 417 417 417.0 0.00103 0.00103 0.00103
358 4647 1 0 1
359 4644 2 0 2 398 398 398.0 0.001944 0.001944 0.001944
360 4732 1 0 1
361 4910 1 0 1
362 4470 1 1 0
363 4737 1 0 1
364 4920 1 0 1
365 5125 1 0 1
366 4627 1 0 1
367 4884 1 0 1
368 4597 35 0 35 394 394 394.0 0.022988 0.000372 0.007171117647058824
369 4465 34 0 34 383 383 383.0 0.018807 0.000364 0.005009666666666667
370 4697 64 7 57 26323 698 24090.0 1.030364 0.001276 0.1931083333333333
371 4641 65 5 60 23805 642 22240.0 1.984989 0.000734 0.21763387499999998
372 4664 19 0 19 400 400 400.0 0.055555 0.000399 0.005936333333333333
373 4694 19 0 19 402 402 402.0 0.026396 0.00044 0.005943944444444444
374 4787 37 0 37 726 416 680.0 0.056771 0.000655 0.012783333333333336
375 4809 37 0 37 697 418 678.0 0.061221 0.000786 0.010880361111111111
376 4483 21 0 21 385 385 385.0 0.021498 0.000383 0.007484349999999999
377 4677 11 0 11 401 401 401.0 0.014198 0.000361 0.0026276
378 4587 45 5 40 15751 15109 15656.0 1.321379 0.022048 0.22873999999999992
379 4732 22 0 22 504 496 502.0 0.05338 0.000536 0.01617090476190476
380 4727 11 0 11 405 405 405.0 0.008131 0.000495 0.0025351
381 4908 6 0 6 420 420 420.0 0.017446 0.000564 0.0041475999999999996
382 4730 23 0 23 594 585 592.0 0.070342 0.00065 0.013495272727272724
383 4843 11 0 11 417 417 417.0 0.029881 0.000694 0.009650099999999998
384 4768 30 0 30 408 408 408.0 0.033587 0.000436 0.008093793103448276
385 4622 68 5 63 12362 11678 11955.0 1.077353 0.015741 0.15566234328358206
386 4874 31 0 31 419 419 419.0 0.040599 0.000441 0.009222733333333335
387 4584 67 3 64 9041 540 5292.0 0.971151 0.000695 0.08751284848484848
388 4603 31 0 31 394 394 394.0 0.018894 0.000413 0.005867733333333333
389 4566 72 2 70 13225 526 6177.0 1.109463 0.000478 0.08201674647887325
390 4598 27 0 27 394 394 394.0 0.022414 0.000396 0.005126923076923076
391 4591 66 3 63 4665 396 2706.0 0.450731 0.000324 0.051266800000000015
392 4474 104 3 101 35626 770 11495.0 3.062043 0.000846 0.1439266796116505
393 4738 105 1 104 35668 803 6554.0 2.010033 0.000893 0.07351879807692309
394 4839 101 4 97 35569 421 15567.0 2.387245 0.000436 0.17715432999999997
395 4866 104 2 102 35649 424 8060.0 1.379257 0.000412 0.06237811650485437
396 4639 112 4 108 35643 407 12872.0 1.777006 0.000386 0.11943261261261262
397 4878 120 4 116 35628 427 11879.0 1.943148 0.00039 0.1040158487394958
398 4754 104 4 100 34782 408 20463.0 2.427207 0.000376 0.20670459223300966
399 4939 117 5 112 35556 423 21489.0 2.864864 0.000462 0.22705166379310343
400 4586 21 0 21 394 394 394.0 0.047973 0.00046 0.010071199999999999
401 4490 49 3 46 676 576 642.0 0.101147 0.000792 0.015656104166666667
402 4958 9 0 9 425 425 425.0 0.040535 0.000399 0.01302675
403 4625 24 0 24 396 396 396.0 0.029705 0.000375 0.0073292608695652165
404 4603 16 0 16 395 395 395.0 0.040206 0.000358 0.012326733333333333
405 4562 43 3 40 397 391 395.0 0.079189 0.000322 0.009798333333333334
406 4810 7 0 7 412 412 412.0 0.032593 0.000369 0.010081833333333333
407 4682 22 0 22 402 402 402.0 0.078205 0.000331 0.01077247619047619
408 4663 76 5 71 24699 407 20216.0 2.342201 0.00051 0.27327171999999983
409 4714 81 3 78 35366 799 16662.0 2.013789 0.00095 0.1843358625
410 4717 40 0 40 480 405 453.0 0.046294 0.000392 0.012555666666666666
411 4781 47 0 47 827 419 544.0 0.062231 0.00048 0.011631804347826086
412 4680 71 5 66 16395 401 14611.0 1.435987 0.000375 0.25640355714285706
413 4808 81 6 75 33768 753 26507.0 2.607196 0.000963 0.2028044125
414 4701 37 0 37 410 403 408.0 0.044317 0.000376 0.007218472222222221
415 4776 44 0 44 691 411 582.0 0.093714 0.000391 0.01211246511627907
416 4537 21 0 21 389 389 389.0 0.059459 0.000367 0.006652749999999999
417 4589 50 4 46 18833 583 15336.0 1.570065 0.000702 0.19838595918367344
418 4707 16 0 16 404 404 404.0 0.02651 0.00088 0.007709066666666667
419 4560 43 3 40 6224 391 5333.0 0.46456 0.000331 0.0632607619047619
420 4907 11 0 11 420 420 420.0 0.045555 0.000518 0.0084925
421 4756 26 0 26 655 412 585.0 0.059082 0.000385 0.010911120000000002
422 4997 8 0 8 428 428 428.0 0.018264 0.000888 0.004188142857142856
423 4662 22 0 22 507 399 490.0 0.033772 0.000353 0.008025714285714285
424 4573 82 5 77 35277 402 22154.0 2.837039 0.00038 0.1992594567901235
425 4818 89 5 84 35182 806 27487.0 2.668561 0.000923 0.2510617159090909
426 4656 75 4 71 33359 399 26972.0 3.605494 0.000393 0.23070352702702704
427 4733 85 6 79 35186 803 26906.0 2.148385 0.001151 0.2534797261904762
428 4791 43 0 43 824 410 598.0 0.061868 0.000381 0.012763071428571426
429 4801 50 0 50 828 418 692.0 0.105314 0.000458 0.01660542857142857
430 4864 39 0 39 813 417 708.0 0.077749 0.000402 0.011219026315789474
431 4819 47 0 47 830 419 704.0 0.12412 0.000404 0.01775360869565218
432 4802 10 0 10 412 412 412.0 0.032166 0.001549 0.017082666666666666
433 4539 28 1 27 389 389 389.0 0.03609 0.000333 0.007853185185185185
434 4879 4 0 4 419 419 419.0 0.006336 0.001397 0.003171666666666667
435 4611 14 0 14 395 395 395.0 0.032176 0.000359 0.004410692307692308
436 4963 4 0 4 426 426 426.0 0.027804 0.003123 0.018338666666666666
437 4680 13 0 13 401 401 401.0 0.053547 0.000353 0.014278583333333332
438 5121 1 0 1
439 4895 6 0 6 419 419 419.0 0.002139 0.000369 0.0009146
440 4603 51 5 46 8138 394 7770.0 0.621619 0.000386 0.11887989999999997
441 4716 59 6 53 27410 26301 27193.0 2.486348 0.040779 0.2281169827586206
442 4632 26 0 26 397 397 397.0 0.074324 0.000361 0.007343720000000001
443 4744 32 0 32 416 415 416.0 0.039913 0.000351 0.006988709677419356
444 4702 25 0 25 457 403 451.0 0.043997 0.0004 0.013928625
445 4706 30 0 30 664 650 661.0 0.112822 0.000748 0.017773827586206895
446 4859 12 0 12 417 417 417.0 0.031074 0.000372 0.004786181818181818
447 4733 16 0 16 405 405 405.0 0.033453 0.000516 0.006051666666666667
448 4897 107 6 101 35565 33683 34325.0 2.645486 0.048617 0.2759087735849056
449 4650 117 2 115 35626 787 11202.0 1.791986 0.000833 0.06600013793103447
450 5058 109 4 105 35732 831 12667.0 2.009291 0.000859 0.11539344444444445
451 4974 123 4 119 35507 434 14205.0 1.231043 0.000446 0.09115389344262297
452 5005 122 1 121 35599 832 7269.0 1.296529 0.000915 0.0766922561983471
453 4770 127 6 121 35574 417 12855.0 3.740406 0.000396 0.12524660317460318
454 5064 122 4 118 35542 442 12207.0 1.872247 0.000406 0.09492408264462804
455 4957 130 5 125 35538 424 14981.0 1.966265 0.000435 0.14356921705426354
456 4554 86 5 81 34474 397 19853.0 2.973064 0.000401 0.15387572941176472
457 4677 46 0 46 723 401 519.0 0.085646 0.000392 0.011321000000000003
458 4732 89 4 85 30690 411 18431.0 1.739284 0.000686 0.12749639772727275
459 4695 48 0 48 498 403 445.0 0.070023 0.000396 0.00976304255319149
460 4533 88 6 82 35102 397 21665.0 3.031303 0.00034 0.17297327586206898
461 4772 45 0 45 830 409 634.0 0.13479 0.000348 0.017723477272727273
462 4644 90 4 86 27091 400 18316.0 2.759531 0.000395 0.1462850786516854
463 4641 46 0 46 453 398 429.0 0.104275 0.000357 0.007952155555555554
464 4788 82 4 78 35243 419 22832.0 1.589552 0.000755 0.18275070370370367
465 4735 86 4 82 34216 412 21257.0 3.345671 0.000393 0.2542693764705883
466 4892 48 0 48 832 419 617.0 0.048519 0.000446 0.013317765957446806
467 4819 49 0 49 726 413 554.0 0.038178 0.000361 0.0082098125
468 4822 83 5 78 34963 420 22461.0 2.44696 0.000458 0.20808632926829274
469 4702 84 5 79 29335 407 24187.0 2.070507 0.000404 0.1608520240963856
470 4645 44 0 44 758 399 593.0 0.05755 0.000389 0.01065479069767442
471 4582 45 0 45 515 394 476.0 0.034257 0.000358 0.006913636363636363
472 4662 60 5 55 11136 491 8511.0 1.083163 0.000576 0.1518878813559322
473 4734 31 0 31 406 406 406.0 0.048088 0.000472 0.010535466666666667
474 4866 33 0 33 417 417 417.0 0.038007 0.000418 0.009182343750000002
475 4893 17 0 17 419 419 419.0 0.06294 0.000539 0.0093403125
476 4484 58 7 51 5364 419 5145.0 0.261769 0.000609 0.047153982456140345
477 4727 29 0 29 405 405 405.0 0.034762 0.000366 0.0063151785714285705
478 4697 31 0 31 403 403 403.0 0.028912 0.000386 0.0056612
479 4925 16 0 16 422 422 422.0 0.042014 0.000402 0.009589733333333333
480 4768 93 7 86 35230 417 18915.0 1.356041 0.000426 0.11487182608695652
481 4712 92 7 85 35223 411 24164.0 1.253467 0.000408 0.13666809890109888
482 4747 92 4 88 35260 415 23816.0 4.385892 0.000431 0.2551370549450549
483 4810 92 5 87 35180 420 27049.0 2.063221 0.000409 0.20561160439560433
484 4779 52 0 52 831 410 545.0 0.109925 0.000376 0.013762313725490201
485 5030 51 0 51 854 431 657.0 0.113004 0.000493 0.011624299999999999
486 4864 51 0 51 838 417 626.0 0.108181 0.000395 0.01531288
487 4769 49 0 49 829 410 690.0 0.168691 0.000383 0.017501604166666667
488 4529 64 6 58 34834 782 28737.0 0.840911 0.000907 0.15293260317460325
489 4700 31 0 31 806 411 712.0 0.064498 0.000452 0.013004799999999999
490 4534 66 5 61 26892 504 23483.0 1.320047 0.000522 0.14104806153846153
491 4722 32 0 32 509 405 491.0 0.043317 0.0004 0.009192580645161293
492 4762 33 0 33 817 414 715.0 0.13401 0.000606 0.018534718749999995
493 4914 16 0 16 430 420 427.0 0.032486 0.000537 0.011139133333333336
494 4825 33 0 33 737 415 675.0 0.095071 0.000385 0.0099645
495 4936 15 0 15 424 423 424.0 0.030645 0.00039 0.01171842857142857
496 4563 62 5 57 30962 750 28752.0 2.497906 0.001256 0.2965245409836066
497 4604 59 6 53 21928 502 20663.0 0.991498 0.000552 0.12354541379310344
498 4704 33 0 33 443 404 438.0 0.039556 0.000417 0.010182187499999999
499 4581 32 0 32 395 393 395.0 0.030057 0.000359 0.005512225806451612
500 4679 32 0 32 709 407 666.0 0.08843 0.000411 0.01497041935483871
501 4697 29 0 29 583 404 567.0 0.041782 0.000377 0.008812607142857143
502 4859 17 0 17 416 416 416.0 0.02546 0.000419 0.004625125
503 4940 15 0 15 423 423 423.0 0.029683 0.000334 0.006086142857142858
504 4587 41 4 37 2074 1818 2041.0 0.08827 0.002139 0.0208681
505 4644 20 0 20 398 398 398.0 0.016099 0.000404 0.003742052631578947
506 4663 22 0 22 400 400 400.0 0.038095 0.000426 0.008067095238095238
507 4810 11 0 11 412 412 412.0 0.022261 0.000391 0.0048446999999999995
508 4595 20 0 20 405 401 404.0 0.031597 0.000323 0.008233894736842103
509 4723 9 0 9 404 404 404.0 0.036299 0.000321 0.011594375
510 4803 10 0 10 411 411 411.0 0.029019 0.000336 0.005391999999999999
511 5033 4 0 4 430 430 430.0 0.002389 0.000346 0.0010416666666666667
Retrieved from "https://crtc.cs.odu.edu/index.php?title=PDR.PODM_Distributed_Memory&oldid=5598"